Will asking my teen about suicide put the idea in their head? What the evidence says

No, and the evidence points the other way

Asking a teenager directly whether they are thinking about suicide does not put the idea in their head. The 988 Suicide and Crisis Lifeline's #BeThe1To initiative cites studies showing that asking at-risk individuals if they are suicidal does not increase suicides or suicidal thoughts, and says that acknowledging and talking about suicide may reduce suicidal thoughts rather than increase them. If you are worried about your teen, asking plainly is one of the most protective things you can do.

At Grant Halliburton Foundation this is one of the beliefs we work hardest to undo, in student presentations, in training for teachers and parents, and in conversations with families across North Texas. The Foundation was founded in 2006 in memory of Grant Halliburton, a Dallas teenager who lived with depression and bipolar disorder and died by suicide at nineteen. Silence protects no one. This guide is general information; it does not replace a licensed professional, and if your teen is in immediate danger, call 911 or go to an emergency room now.

Where the fear comes from

The fear is understandable. Suicide is frightening, and naming it out loud can feel like inviting it into the house. Parents worry that a teen who had never considered it will start to, or that asking will make an already fragile child feel accused or exposed. Some families grew up in homes where the word was never spoken at all.

But a teenager who is not thinking about suicide will usually just say so, perhaps with an eye roll. A teenager who is thinking about it is often carrying that thought alone, waiting to see whether anyone will notice or whether it is safe to say. A direct question tells them that it is. It tells them that you can handle the answer, and that you would rather know than not know.

Why a vague question is not enough

Many parents try to approach the topic sideways: are you okay, you seem down, is something going on. Those are good openers, and they often lead somewhere. But they are easy to deflect with a quick I'm fine, and they leave the most important question unasked.

#BeThe1To suggests asking directly, with a question as simple as: are you thinking about suicide? Using the actual word removes ambiguity. A teen who has been having those thoughts no longer has to guess whether you mean what they fear you mean, and you no longer have to read between the lines of their answer. It is uncomfortable for a few seconds. That discomfort is a small price for a clear answer.

Some teenagers find it easier to answer hard questions in writing than out loud. If your teen shuts down in person, a text or a note that says you have been worried, asks the question directly and tells them you are ready to talk whenever they are can open a door that a face-to-face conversation could not. Follow it up in person as soon as they respond, and if the answer worries you, go to them right away.

Other beliefs that keep parents quiet

The idea that asking causes harm is not the only myth that gets in the way. These are others we hear often, and what the sources we rely on say about them.

• Teens who talk about it will not act on it. The National Institute of Mental Health lists talking about wanting to die, feeling great guilt or shame, or being a burden to others among the warning signs of suicide. Take it seriously every time.
• It is just for attention. Even if a teen is seeking attention, they are telling you they need help. Respond to the need.
• If they make me promise to keep it secret, I should. The 988 Lifeline's guidance is never to keep it a secret if someone tells you about a plan to hurt themselves.
• Someone who is determined will always find a way. #BeThe1To notes that when lethal means are made less available or less deadly, suicide rates by that method decline, and that this belief often does not hold when safety measures are in place.
• I should wait until I am sure something is wrong. The NIMH advises getting help as soon as possible, particularly if a warning sign is new or has increased recently.

How to ask: words that work

Choose a private moment when neither of you is rushed. Side-by-side settings, such as a drive or a walk, often feel less intense for teenagers than sitting face to face. Start with what you have noticed, without judgment, then ask the direct question and wait.

You might say something like this: I have noticed you have not been sleeping and you stopped going to practice, and I am worried about you. Sometimes when people feel this low, they think about suicide. Are you thinking about suicide? Then stop talking. Let the silence sit. Teens often need a moment to decide whether you really want to hear the answer.

Whatever they say, thank them for telling you. Listen more than you speak. Do not argue about whether their feelings make sense, and do not rush to fix it. The 988 Lifeline advises allowing the person to express emotions without judgment and not debating whether suicide is right or wrong. Your job in that moment is to understand, not to persuade.

If the answer is yes

Stay calm, and stay with them. If you believe your teen is in immediate danger, do not leave them alone, and call 911 or go to the nearest emergency room. Otherwise, call or text 988 together, or chat at 988lifeline.org; the Lifeline says its conversations are free and confidential and that it is available 24/7. Our Get Help Now page also lists the Crisis Text Line: text HOME to 741741.

#BeThe1To recommends gently asking about any prior attempts, whether there is a specific plan, its timing, and whether your teen has access to the chosen method, and then creating distance between your teen and high-lethality means such as firearms and medications. It also recommends helping the person connect to ongoing support, including mental health professionals, and considering a safety plan together.

Then follow up. A check-in the next day and the day after tells your teen that the conversation was not a one-time event. Our guide on the first weeks after a mental health crisis covers what families can do once the immediate danger has passed.

If the answer is no, or I don't know

If your teen says no and you believe them, you have still done something important: you have shown that this is a subject your family can talk about. Tell them that if that ever changes, you want them to come to you, and that you will not be angry or panic. Then keep the door open by checking in again over the following weeks.

If the answer is uncertain, or you still have a strong sense that something is wrong, trust that instinct. You do not need a yes to get a professional opinion. Our free Here For Texas Mental Health Navigation Line at 972-525-8181, Monday through Friday from 10 a.m. to 6 p.m., connects you with a trained navigator who helps identify therapists and programs that fit your family. It is not a crisis line. Our guide on what to do when your teenager has changed walks through the warning signs and next steps in more detail.

After the conversation, look after yourself

Asking your child about suicide is one of the hardest things a parent can do, and hearing the answer can be harder. The 988 Lifeline reminds people supporting someone through a difficult time that it is important to take care of themselves, and the Lifeline is available to you as a parent as well as to your teen. Talk with your partner, a trusted friend or your own counselor. Moms and female caregivers in the Dallas area are welcome at our free Coffee Days support groups, where other mothers understand without needing the backstory explained.

It is also normal to replay the conversation afterward and wish you had said something differently. You do not need perfect words. What your teen will remember is that you noticed, that you asked, and that you stayed. If you stumbled, you can always come back the next day and say so: I have been thinking about our talk, and I want you to know I am here.

Learning this before you need it

The best time to practice this conversation is before you need it. Our Building Blocks of Mental Health presentations teach students in third through 12th grade, and teachers, parents and professionals, to recognize the warning signs of depression and suicidal crisis, start supportive conversations and connect young people to help. Our TAG, You're It wallet card, available in English and Spanish, puts the warning signs, what to do and where to find help in a pocket.

If you are an educator, our guide on the warning signs teachers notice and what to do applies the same approach to the classroom. If you lead a school, parent group, faith community or workplace in Dallas or anywhere in North Texas and want this training for your people, reach out to me. Every adult who learns to ask the question is one more person a struggling teen might be able to answer honestly.

Questions people ask me